Hey, I definitely was not expecting Siobhan Magnus to leave tonight, even if I was not a big fan of her most recent performances. When Ryan announced the bottom three of Casey, Mike and Siobhan, I was guessing at that point it was bound to be Big Mike going home tonight. I found it hard to believe Aaron Kelly was not in the bottom three. How many people can there be to vote for him in Sonestown, PA? I suppose he probably does have the teen and tween fan base as well as the country fan base to help his cause. This had been Siobhan's first time ever in the bottom three and had I assumed she would be one of the two to survive. But, unfortunately, I was wrong and now only one lady is left remaining, Crystal, and the four guys, Lee, Casey, Mike and Aaron. Why have all the other ladies been voted off from the top 12? Only two guys have been eliminated and now Crystal Bowersox represents all the female vocals left in the competition. I guess Crystal also gets her own room in the Idol Mansion now for her duration on the show. You would think with only five contestants left they would each get their own room in the mansion by now. I wonder how that works.
In any case I will miss Siobhan even if I never enjoyed her screaming. She actually has a great voice and since she is only 20, I am guessing she definitely has a future ahead of her in music. On Friday I am going to see "Avenue Q" here in town, and I could definitely envision Siobhan in a Broadway musical type production. Plus she definitely had the best name of any of the contestants on the show. Come on, "Aaron Kelly" or "Casey James" are extremely generic names (much like "Kris Allen" or "David Cook"). Unique artists need unique names!
Wednesday, April 28, 2010
Latest HCD Mediacurves Survey Information
The latest HCD Mediacurves survey shows that even after a disappointing performance last night, Crystal Bowersox continues to receive over a third of their votes (35.2%) more than combined totals of the next two contestants, Casey James (17.4%) and Siobhan Magnus (16.5%). That helps to show the voting is more based on fan popularity as opposed to the performance of the specific night. Crystal's percentage of the votes did drop off substantially but is still considerably in the lead. Aaron Kelly again is in the bottom of the pack, and we will see if tonight is finally the night he is sent home.
Tuesday, April 27, 2010
Shania Twain night throws Idol Wacky!
Now that we are down to only six contestants, they decided to pull a "Shania Twain" night and the results were not pretty. The bottom line was nobody was awful and nobody was really fantastic with everybody ending up extremely mediocre. That turns the voting into a pure popularity contest so it will be very interesting to see who goes home tomorrow night. This is actually good news for Aaron Kelley who was probably next to go for sure if the front runners had performed well, but since they did not he may survive the week. Aaron actually performed better than usual although I still would not say his performance was great. The closest one to being great this week was someone else who needed it, Casey James. After his stale performance last week where he was in the bottom two, he is probably the safest contestant this week. Lee was his same old self which probably means he is safe, but the usually top-notch Crystal Bowersox was definitely not at her usual level. She needs to tone down the supporting band which did not help out her performance at all. Big Mike again pulled out a ballad which as usual sounded great vocally but made me cringe watching him grimace and emote. The most polarizing performance, however, was definitely Siobhan Magnus who poured out a performance you either loved or hated. Unfortunately for me I was in the latter category. She has a great voice and does not need to screech and yell at the end of every upbeat song. I simply would never vote for her. She is definitely the person most in need of a talented producer to channel her very capable talents into something wonderful.
So how would I rank the performances?
1) Casey James 6.4/10 - not really that great but the best of the pack tonight -- too much like "Jealous Man" part II
2) Lee Dewyze 6.0/10 - he had pitch problems and was not as strong as last week. He is still probably safe though
3) Crystal Bowersox 5.4/10 - awful arrangement of the song. She could have done this so much better.
4) Big Mike Lynch 5.0/10 - nice vocals on yet another ballad. I still cannot enjoy watching him sing though.
5) Aaron Kelly 4.8/10 - more emotive than usual but still not that exciting
6) Siobhan Magnus 4.5/10 - started nice but never built until the end which was way overdone. She has more vocal talent than most of the guys here but needs real guidance (and not from the Idol judges for sure).
Having put Siobhan in last place, I really do not think she will go home. I am guessing Aaron and Mike will be in the bottom three based solely on their previous votes in the bottom three before and one of those two will be leaving. I think this week's voting will be very indicative of overall long term popularity of the contestants and not so much about the performances of this evening. It will be very interesting to see who the bottom three are besides Aaron and Mike. It could be anybody else as the third person in the bottom. I would be shocked if Crystal were in the bottom three, but if she were that may actually put her large fan base into a frenzy that would guarantee she win the whole thing. Frankly, since I believe either Aaron or Mike is going home tomorrow, being the third "bottom dweller" might help any other contestant by firing up their fans. I do not think Aaron nor Mike have the fan base of the other four contestants and they are bound to be voted off in the next couple weeks.
So how would I rank the performances?
1) Casey James 6.4/10 - not really that great but the best of the pack tonight -- too much like "Jealous Man" part II
2) Lee Dewyze 6.0/10 - he had pitch problems and was not as strong as last week. He is still probably safe though
3) Crystal Bowersox 5.4/10 - awful arrangement of the song. She could have done this so much better.
4) Big Mike Lynch 5.0/10 - nice vocals on yet another ballad. I still cannot enjoy watching him sing though.
5) Aaron Kelly 4.8/10 - more emotive than usual but still not that exciting
6) Siobhan Magnus 4.5/10 - started nice but never built until the end which was way overdone. She has more vocal talent than most of the guys here but needs real guidance (and not from the Idol judges for sure).
Having put Siobhan in last place, I really do not think she will go home. I am guessing Aaron and Mike will be in the bottom three based solely on their previous votes in the bottom three before and one of those two will be leaving. I think this week's voting will be very indicative of overall long term popularity of the contestants and not so much about the performances of this evening. It will be very interesting to see who the bottom three are besides Aaron and Mike. It could be anybody else as the third person in the bottom. I would be shocked if Crystal were in the bottom three, but if she were that may actually put her large fan base into a frenzy that would guarantee she win the whole thing. Frankly, since I believe either Aaron or Mike is going home tomorrow, being the third "bottom dweller" might help any other contestant by firing up their fans. I do not think Aaron nor Mike have the fan base of the other four contestants and they are bound to be voted off in the next couple weeks.
I figured out my Facebook Fan Page Problem
Most of the Facebook fan pages are actually still there, it is just not very easy to find them anymore. For some reason, now I have to type their name into the search field, and then click the "See More Results for ..." selection to find their fan pages. But when I do that, then the old Fan pages show up with the proper counts except for Tim Urban's which does seem to be gone. There are actually a ton of Tim Urban Facebook pages out there, but none that had the ~20,000 fans he had last week. Oh well, he has been eliminated so I can stop tracking him. However, since I can still find Andrew and Katie fan pages, I can still track them just to keep their lines going. In reality, it now appears that just about all the contestants have "flatlined" on my graph except for Crystal Bowersox and Lee Dewyze. My latest data point is actually 5 days since my last sampling (April 22) and those two are the only ones to have significantly increased. In the five day period Crystal has added about 6,300 new fans (from 73,174 to 79,464) and Lee added about 2,800 (from 37,116 to 39,917) so he is definitely distancing himself from Casey James now. No other contestant added more than 1,000 new fans over the past five days.
So tonight is Shania Twain night with the six contestants performing her songs and being mentored by her. I am guessing she will be fine with Crystal, Lee, Casey and Aaron, and I am curious to see how it goes with Siobhan and Mike. At this point I think Aaron is pretty much a goner in the next week or two, and it is up to Casey, Siobhan and Big Mike to do something wonderful to get into the top three with Crystal and Lee.
Another interesting question is how Tim Urban's departure might help the others in terms of voting. Since he lived in Texas near Casey, I could see his Texan vote adding to Casey's tally. But since Tim was also popular with the teen crowd, I could see his under 20 crowd voting more for Aaron and his cute teen smile. Then there is the VoteForTheWorst crowd who is now supposed to vote for Siobhan, even though many on the board actually wanted to vote for Aaron instead. It will be interesting to see who will be in the bottom three tomorrow, but a lot depends on what transpires tonight.
I am also curious who the west coast crowd are voting for now that all the contestants live in the central and eastern time zones. We now have one from Texas, one from Illinois, one from Ohio, one from Florida, one from Pennsylvania and one from Massachusetts. I have even added a US map with the hometowns of the six remaining contestants in red and all the previous Idol winners in green. It is interesting that Mount Prospect IL, Elliston, OH, Sonestown, PA and Barnstable, MA almost all would fit on a straight lattitude line as you travel east. Four of the six remaining contestants including both of the front runners, Crystal and Lee, are from north of the Mason Dixon line. None of the previous winners have been northerners before with the winner living furthest north being David Cook from Blue Springs, MO. And if it ends up being Crystal and Lee in the finals that would make for a midwestern final, where both contestants had been in the Chicago music scene.
Monday, April 26, 2010
Facebook turned off the Fan Based Pages!
Alas, it appears that Facebook must have taken all the fan created pages for the contestants except for Crystal's, Michael's and Tim's. So that means I cannot keep updating my lovely Facebook Fan graphs! How sad. I did note that Crystal's fan count is up to over 78,000 now, so maybe the other fan pages took themselves down so they would not be compared.
I thought another interesting graph would be layering the line graphs for the WhatNotToSing web ratings for the remaining contestants. Now that we are down to six, it is now much easier to see them all together over the nine weeks they have been performing. Just showing the overall average of the contestants at the current time does not demonstrate their change over time as well, but my lovely line graph does demonstrate the ebbs and flows of each contestant over the past two months. Some contestants like Crystal and Aaron have been very consistent (consistently good for Crystal, consistently bad for Aaron), but the remaining four contestants have varied quite a bit. I even added a spline to the curves here since I thought the pointed lines were too much. I definitely believe Aaron, Casey and Mike are the ones to worry this week and who really have to deliver a great performance or risk going home Wednesday. Since it is Shania Twain week this should make for some interesting performances.
I thought another interesting graph would be layering the line graphs for the WhatNotToSing web ratings for the remaining contestants. Now that we are down to six, it is now much easier to see them all together over the nine weeks they have been performing. Just showing the overall average of the contestants at the current time does not demonstrate their change over time as well, but my lovely line graph does demonstrate the ebbs and flows of each contestant over the past two months. Some contestants like Crystal and Aaron have been very consistent (consistently good for Crystal, consistently bad for Aaron), but the remaining four contestants have varied quite a bit. I even added a spline to the curves here since I thought the pointed lines were too much. I definitely believe Aaron, Casey and Mike are the ones to worry this week and who really have to deliver a great performance or risk going home Wednesday. Since it is Shania Twain week this should make for some interesting performances.
Thursday, April 22, 2010
Down to Six Contestants and my Latest Facebbok Fan Graph
Now that "Idols Gives Back" is over I thought it was time for my next graph! I am still tracking Andrew and Katie (along with the recently departed Tim) just because I can . When Ryan said the show was going to run late, I did not imagine it would be THAT late, but it seemed mean to not let Tim sing a final farewell song. He kept on smiling though, since that is what he does best. Looking at the numbers from early Tuesday to today, Tim actually was still gaining fans well, adding almost 2,000 in that time (from 19,424 to 21,351). He was still gaining the third highest number of new fans, behind only Lee (gaining about 3,000 going from 34,052 to 37,118) and Crystal Bowersox, of course, who tacked on nearly 7,000 new Facebook fans in two days (from 66,252 to 73,174). Crystal gained more new fans in the past two days than Big Mike Lynch has in total. I noticed some of the other contestants have pretty much stopped gaining many new fans which does not look good for them if Lee keeps increasing steadily and Crystal adds new fans by leaps and bounds. For example, the now departed Andrew and Katie added 300-400 new fans, and Aaron and Casey each only gained about 500. Siobhan did gain almost 900 (from 22,435 to 23,315) but Mike only added 150 (from 6275 to 6425). Since Big Mike was not in the bottom three, however, I am just guessing his fan base is not populated by a lot of Facebook users! I was a bit surprised by Casey being in the bottom three since I thought he had a ton of fans, but then again so did Andrew.
Since I love numbers I also investigated the final web rankings on WhatNotToSing, where the rankings this week actually perfectly selected the bottom three and Tim's elimination as well. Crystal scored another very high ranking of 90 this week, which means after only 9 performances Bowersox has scored 8 "five star" ratings. In terms of five star performances, Mamasox is already in third place on WhatNotToSing's list of top contestants of all time which is pretty staggering. Her average web ranking of 84.1 puts her number 1 of all contestants and she has never scored below four stars (her lowest score is a 78). I will be curious to see if she can continue this impressive streak for her remaining time on Idol, which hopefully will be until the finale, but with the voting patterns of America, you never know for sure.
Since I love numbers I also investigated the final web rankings on WhatNotToSing, where the rankings this week actually perfectly selected the bottom three and Tim's elimination as well. Crystal scored another very high ranking of 90 this week, which means after only 9 performances Bowersox has scored 8 "five star" ratings. In terms of five star performances, Mamasox is already in third place on WhatNotToSing's list of top contestants of all time which is pretty staggering. Her average web ranking of 84.1 puts her number 1 of all contestants and she has never scored below four stars (her lowest score is a 78). I will be curious to see if she can continue this impressive streak for her remaining time on Idol, which hopefully will be until the finale, but with the voting patterns of America, you never know for sure.
Wednesday, April 21, 2010
New HCD Mediacurves poll results released
I just received the results via e-mail of the HCD Research Mediacurves poll after last night's episode of American Idol. Last week I was curious where Katie and Andrew's 15% of the vote would end up, and it looks like most of it ended up with Crystal! Crystal's number was up to a staggering 44.5% of the vote this week with Siobhan surprisingly number two, but at a distant 12.4%. Lee and Casey are pretty much tied at 10.8/10.7% with Mike right behind them at 9.6%. Finally Tim has 7.3% and Aaron again is at the bottom with 4.8%. Last night only 3,081 people responded so their level of response keeps getting lower. So for this week Crystal Bowersox received more votes than Siobhan, Lee, Casey and Mike combined. So much for the backlash from her "quitting" rumor...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





